HOME
ABOUT IAC
CONTACT
A-Z INDEX
DONATE
SHOP
SUBSCRIBE
Immunization Action Coalition
Press Room
Immunization Action Coalition
Contact: Julie Murphy
(651) 647-9009
Email: julie@immunize.org
Immunization Action Coalition
October 12, 2009
 
Letter to CBS Evening News regarding report How Independent Are Vaccine Defenders? originally broadcast on July 25, 2008
In response to the report, Immunization Action Coalition wrote the following letter to CBS Managing Editor Katie Couric. In the letter, IAC's Executive Director Deborah Wexler, MD, reminds Ms. Couric that the advocacy journalism behind How Independent Are Vaccine Defenders? reduces CBS News' hard-earned reputation for journalistic professionalism and has the potential to increase the risk that children of viewers will contract serious illness.
August 3, 2008

Katie Couric, Managing Editor
CBS Evening News
524 West 57th Street
6th Floor
New York, NY 10019-2902
Dear Ms. Couric:
I am Executive Director of the Immunization Action Coalition (IAC), a national nonprofit organization with eighteen years' experience providing information about vaccines to healthcare professionals and the public. Before founding the Coalition, I practiced family medicine with a special focus on refugee and immigrant health.
Your report of July 25, 2008, How Independent Are Vaccine Defenders?, is an example of advocacy journalism that can harm the health of the nation's children by unnecessarily undermining confidence in the immunization community.
The report adopts a sensational tone of wrongdoing while saying there has been none.  It refers to critics while naming none. It "discovers" facts that it says are public record.  It arouses suspicions too ill-defined to be rebutted.  It concludes (unnamed) critics "worry that industry ties could impact the advice given to the public about all those vaccines," and cites no example of compromised advice ever occurring, either in the past or present.
Leaving aside the reprehensible defamation this piece of pure advocacy inflicts on exemplary pillars of the immunization community, the report has the potential to increase the risk that children of viewers will contract serious illness.
Physicians who provide care for children will tell you they are seeing increased hesitancy on the part of parents to have their children immunized. Several state health departments have tracked an increase in the number of parents claiming exemptions from vaccination for their children. The safety of vaccines is not changing.  What is occurring is a drumbeat of media reporting that incorrectly depicts the claims of vaccine opponents as scientifically plausible.
Advocacy journalism, or even the appearance of it, reduces CBS News' hard-earned reputation for journalistic professionalism.  By giving credence to the views of fringe critics whose own motivations are not reported on, CBS News elevates their assertions to the level of those made by legitimate experts, creating needless confusion among the lay public.
It has been said that a news organization has only its credibility and reputation to rely on. CBS News' descent into advocacy has damaged something far more important than its credibility and reputation, and the children who endure serious illness will never know of CBS News' supporting role in their suffering.
Sincerely,
Deborah L. Wexler, MD


cc:  Katie Boyle, Senior Producer
  Jonathan LaPook, M.D., Medical Correspondent
  Paul Friedman, Senior Vice President, CBS News
This page was updated on August 4, 2008.
This page was reviewed on August 4, 2008.
 
- Guide to immunize.org -
A-Z INDEX
ABOUT IAC
IAC in the News
Staff
IAC History through Film
ACIP
RECOMMENDATIONS
ADOLESCENT VACCINATION
ADULT VACCINATION
ADULT VACCINATION GUIDE
ASK THE EXPERTS
Administering Vaccines
COVID-19 & Routine Vac
Hepatitis B
MMR
Storage and Handling
>> view all
BECKY PAYNE AWARD
BILLING & CODING
BIRTH DOSE GUIDEBOOK
CALENDAR OF EVENTS
CDC INFORMATION
CDC SCHEDULES
CLINIC TOOLS
Administering Vaccines
Adolescent Vaccination
Adult Vaccination
Screening for Contraindications
Vaccination and COVID-19
Vaccine Recommendations
Vaccine Storage & Handling
>> view all
COALITIONS FOR
IMMUNIZATION
CONTRIBUTE TO IAC
COVID-19 RELATED
Ask the Experts: COVID-19
   & Routine Vac
Clinic Tools: Vaccination and
   COVID-19
Repository of Resources
DEAR COLLEAGUE LETTERS
16-year-old Visit
HPV
MenACWY Dose #2
DONATE TO IAC
EDUCATIONAL MATERIALS
EMAIL NEWS SERVICES
E-NEWSLETTER: IAC EXPRESS
EXEMPTIONS
FAQs
FAVORITES
FDA PACKAGE INSERTS
FILMS ABOUT IAC
GIVE BIRTH TO THE
END OF HEP B
HANDOUTS FOR
PATIENTS & STAFF
View All Materials
Administering Vaccines
Adolescent Vaccination
Adult Vaccination
Contraindications / Precautions
Documenting Vaccination
Healthcare Personnel
Managing Vaccine Reactions
Parent Handouts
Pregnancy and Vaccines
Q&As: Diseases and Vaccines
Q&As: Easy-to-Read
Schedules for Patients
Screening Checklists
Standing Orders Templates
Storage & Handling
Strategies & Policies
Temperature Logs
Top Handouts
Vaccine Confidence
Vaccine Recommendations
>> view all
HEP B BIRTH DOSE
HONOR ROLLS
Hep B Birth Dose
Mandatory Flu Vaccination for HCP
MenB Vaccination for Colleges
IAC EXPRESS
Subscribe to IAC Express
IMAGE LIBRARY
LAWS AND MANDATES
MANUFACTURERS
MASS VACCINATION
RESOURCES
NATIONAL ADULT &
INFLUENZA
IMMUNIZATION SUMMIT
NEWS & INFORMATION
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
OFFICIAL RELEASES
ACIP
CDC
FDA
PACKAGE INSERTS
PARTNERS
PHARMACISTS
PHOTOS
POWERPOINT SLIDE SETS
PREGNANCY AND
VACCINES
PRESS ROOM
PROTECT NEWBORNS
FROM HEP B
PUBLICATIONS
IAC Express
Vaccinating Adults:
   A Step-by-Step Guide
Hepatitis B What Hospitals
   Need to Do to
   Protect Newborns
Needle Tips Archive
Vaccinate Adults Archive
Vaccinate Women Archive
REGISTRIES
SCHOOL VACCINATION REQUIREMENTS
SHOP IAC
DVD Immunization Techniques
Laminated Schedules
Patient Record Cards
Flu Vaccine Buttons and Stickers
"Vaccines Save Lives" Pins
SITE MAP
SLIDE SETS
STANDING ORDERS
STATE INFORMATION
Immunization Websites
Laws and Mandates for School Entry
Immunization Program Managers
SUBSCRIBE TO IAC EXPRESS
SUPPORT IAC
TALKING ABOUT VACCINES
Adjuvants & Ingredients
Autism
Importance of Vaccination
MMR Vaccine
Religious Concerns
Vaccine Safety
>> view all
TECHNICALLY SPEAKING
TRANSLATIONS
IAC Handouts
VISs
TRAVEL (INTERNATIONAL)
UNPROTECTED PEOPLE
STORIES
Chickenpox
Hepatitis B
Measles
Whooping Cough
>> view all
VACCINATING ADULTS:
A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
VACCINE INFORMATION
STATEMENTS
Translations
VACCINE
MANUFACTURERS
VACCINE POLICY &
LICENSURE
ACIP
FDA
WHO
VACCINE SAFETY
VACCINE TIMELINE
VACCINES
Hepatitis B
HPV (Human papillomavirus)
Influenza
Pertussis
Varicella
>> view all
VIDEO OF THE WEEK
VIDEO LIBRARY
VISs
Translations
WHAT'S NEW OR UPDATED AT IAC
Handouts
VISs and Translations
Web Pages
 
Immunization Action Coalition  •  2550 University Avenue West  •  Suite 415 North  •  Saint Paul, Minnesota  •  55114
tel 651-647-9009  •  fax 651-647-9131
 
 
 
This website is supported in part by a cooperative agreement from the National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases (Grant No. 6NH23IP22550) at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in Atlanta, GA. The website content is the sole responsibility of IAC and does not necessarily represent the official views of CDC.